I first heard Taylor's new solo release, "Criminal," at Back to the Island in February of 2019. At the time, it was being called "This is Criminal," and it got a fair amount of buzz among fans. Naturally, this release prompted me to go back to my blog post from BTTI that year to remember my initial impression. Here's what 2019 me had to say about Taylor's solo set:
I think most people would agree that the highlight was getting to hear "This is Criminal," the song we briefly heard about in the documentary that didn't make the cut for String Theory. He said it was co-written with Imani Coppola at a Fool's Banquet, and it didn't sound like anything I would have expected. His voice was higher for most of it, and the melody was complex in a way that it didn’t stick with me after one listen. I'd definitely be curious to hear a studio version, but he said "first and last time” before he played it, so that probably won't happen.
Oh, how good it is to be wrong. In the years since that performance, "This is Criminal" has grown to feel like a sort of sleeper diehard fan favorite to me--mostly falling back into obscurity, but once in a while drawing a few highly impassioned comments that it's, well, criminal to keep it under wraps.
Cue moderate surprise when it made its second appearance at Taylor's Hotel Cafe show in March of this year and gave fans hope that maybe it wasn't being kept in the vault after all, though I never expected its return was foreshadowing a much bigger release.
So here we are, seven years later with a minor title change and the vault officially opened wide and welcoming guests. "Criminal" is out today, November 20th, on all streaming platforms and came with the added bonus of an absolutely beautiful music video featuring Taylor's Dancing With The Stars partner Britt Stewart. If you haven't already checked out People Magazine's exclusive article, please pause and give it a read to get Taylor's inside take on the song, the video, and how it all came together. I won't waste our time paraphrasing all of the great information included there because it's well worth the firsthand read.
My added two cents is that I'm not usually someone who cares about music videos, but man, do I love this one. The moment Taylor and Britt left DWTS and he had free time to work on his solo music again, it hit me what a great idea it would be to include Britt in a future music video. I had no idea if that would really happen or how it might fit with his music, but her inclusion in the "Criminal" video ended up being better than anything I could have imagined.
The song choice, string arrangement, and Britt's choreography all paired together so flawlessly that the final product came out feeling like it was always meant to be this way. I never would have heard the song as a waltz without all of the added DWTS context, but it is so undeniably a waltz that I can't imagine the song any other way now. Some songs evolve into something that leaves me missing some aspect of the earlier version, but after seeing this music video, "Criminal" feels like it found the final element to make it complete.
And not to make it a single-sentence footnote, but Taylor's voice and piano arrangement also sounded as gorgeous as ever. (Dare I say the falsetto part sounded like Zac? I definitely hear the brother voice similarity in this one.)
The timing of the release is obviously an intentional choice to coincide with the end of the DWTS season, and there are a million ways they could have gotten that formula wrong and left it feeling rushed or forced in order to fit the timeline or make it feel relevant to the show. Instead, they nailed every single part of the video concept, and everything came together in a very natural way. I couldn’t agree more with Taylor’s quote that it serves as a great "time capsule" and "bookend" to their time on the show. Everyone involved should be proud.
On a final note, I'll say I'm glad to know that this song was written years ago at a Fool's Banquet. I think some listeners will hear it as a tongue-in-cheek response to their early DWTS elimination (and maybe there's a clever nod in the timing), or even some kind of commentary on the current state of the band (definitely think that one's purely circumstantial), but the truth is it has been lying in wait for the right moment, the right moment is now, and any thematic similarity is just a great testimony to the reach of a timeless song.
In conclusion, listen, share, buy (yes, you can still do that for a whole $1.29!), swoon, and start saving that PTO and tour fund for whatever comes next because this feels like just the beginning.

.png)
.png)




.png)



.png)

.png)

.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)

.png)
.png)
.png)
